You know those mornings when nothing in your closet feels right? Most of them have the same easy fix: a good oxford shirt and a sweater you actually like wearing. It works at the office, at Thanksgiving dinner and on a chilly Saturday coffee run, and you never have to think too hard about it.
Brooks Brothers is the natural place to start. The brand has been making clothes in New York since 1818, and it calls its button-down collar the Original Polo, a design it says it invented. Below, I'll help you pick the right Brooks Brothers oxford shirt, match it with the right sweater, and buy both without paying more than you need to.
Why an Oxford and a Sweater Just Work
An oxford shirt sits right in the middle. It's dressier than a T-shirt but more relaxed than a stiff dress shirt. Put a sweater over it and you look put together without looking like you tried too hard.
The other reason is how much use you get out of so little. One shirt and one sweater give you four different looks: the shirt on its own, the shirt under a crewneck, a shirt and tie under a V-neck, or the shirt untucked with a quarter-zip. That's a lot of mileage from two pieces.
Which Brooks Brothers Oxford Shirt Should You Buy?
Three shirts cover almost everyone. The right one depends on where you'll wear it most.
For the Office: Non-Iron Pinpoint Oxford
If you wear a collared shirt to work most days, start with the Cotton Non-Iron Pinpoint Oxford Button-Down Collar Dress Shirt. Pinpoint is a smoother, finer take on oxford cloth, so it looks a little sharper under a blazer or with a tie.
The non-iron finish is the real win. It's made to stay virtually wrinkle-free all day, so you can skip the ironing board on busy mornings. It also sits at the top of Brooks Brothers' dress shirt best-seller list. You can get it in White, Blue, Light Blue, Pink and Lavender. If you're only buying two, make them white and light blue. Those go with everything.
For the Purist: American-Made Oxford Cloth Button-Down
The American-Made Oxford Cloth Button-Down Dress Shirt is the one to get if you care about how a shirt is put together. It's made in the USA from 100% cotton oxford cloth, with mother-of-pearl buttons, a chest pocket, a back pleat and Brooks Brothers' signature 6-pleat shirring at the cuffs.
It costs more, and it isn't part of the current two-shirt deal. My advice: don't rush this one. It's the shirt to grab during a big sitewide sale. It comes in Blue, Light Pink and White.
For the Weekend: Friday Oxford
The Friday Oxford Shirt is the easygoing one. The cotton is washed, so it feels soft from day one, and the fit is a little relaxed, so it looks right untucked. It still has the classic button-down collar.
It's the most affordable of the three and one of the brand's best sellers. Colors include Blue, Teal, Pink, White, Yellow and Lavender. Pair it with a non-iron shirt and you've covered work and weekends in one order.
How to Choose Your Fit
The work shirt and the American-made shirt come in three fits, while the Friday Oxford comes in one relaxed fit.
Slim: the most tailored, cut closer to the body.
Regular: the standard fit, made for most body types.
Traditional: the fullest and roomiest.
If you'll wear a sweater over your shirt most days, go Slim or Regular so there's no extra fabric bunching at your waist. If you like room to move, Traditional is the comfortable choice.
The Best Sweaters to Wear Over Your Oxford
Once the shirt is sorted, the sweater is where you add warmth and a bit of personality.
Ultimate Merino: The One You'll Reach for Most ($168 to $198)
If you buy one sweater, make it merino. The Ultimate Merino line is made from Italian merino wool yarn. It keeps you warm without the bulk, so it sits nicely over a collar and still fits under a jacket. Brooks Brothers also says it helps regulate temperature, which is handy when you're going from a cold street into a warm office.
Here's how to pick:
Crewneck if you like your collar showing.
V-Neck ($168) if you wear a tie.
Quarter-Zip for weekends and travel.
Navy, grey and camel are the easiest colors to wear with a white or blue oxford.
Cashmere: The Treat-Yourself Layer
Cashmere is softer and feels like a real step up. The 3-Ply Cashmere Crewneck Saddle Shoulder Sweater uses cashmere from a Scottish mill, spun thicker so it lasts. If you want cashmere without the top price, the Cashmere Waffle-Knit Sweater has a relaxed, textured look that's great on weekends.
One honest tip: none of the cashmere was on sale when we looked, and the holiday sales are only weeks away. If you can wait, wait.
The Cozy Sale Pick: Shetland Cable Crew
If you like chunky knits, look at the Cable Crewneck Sweater in Shetland Wool. Brooks Brothers brought it back as a classic its customers wore for generations. It's 100% Shetland wool, made in the UK, and it has that warm, textured look that's perfect for cold weekends.
Right now it's on clearance at $199.99, down from $398. Only Brown and Burgundy were left, so if your size is there, don't sit on it.
Four Easy Outfits to Try This Week
Office: white non-iron oxford, navy merino V-neck and a tie.
Business casual: light blue oxford and a grey merino crewneck with the collar out, over chinos.
Weekend: white Friday Oxford, untucked, under a Dark Brown merino quarter-zip.
Cold Saturday: blue American-Made oxford under the brown Shetland cable crew.
One care tip: Brooks Brothers recommends hand washing its merino, cashmere waffle-knit and Shetland sweaters. Follow the label and they'll keep looking good much longer.
When to Buy and How to Pay Less
You don't have to pay full price for any of this. Here's how to save:
Buy shirts in pairs. Right now Brooks Brothers takes 25% off when you buy two or more men's shirts. Two non-iron oxfords come to $192, or $96 each.
Check clearance. Besides the Shetland sweater, the Stretch Non-Iron Cotton-Oxford Polo Button-Down Check Sport Shirt is $49.99, down from $118.
Save the big buys for Black Friday. Last year Brooks Brothers ran 30% off sitewide right before Black Friday, with an extra 10% for Rewards members. On Cyber Monday it was 40% off sitewide. This year's deals aren't announced yet, but that's when we'd buy cashmere or the American-Made oxford.
Join Brooks Brothers Rewards. It's free, you earn points on every order, and 2,500 points turn into a $25 reward.
Watch the shipping line. Orders of $200 or more ship free.
Use ID.me if you qualify. Students, teachers, first responders and others can verify for 10% off.
Prices and deals change often, so double-check before you check out.
The Bottom Line
You don't need a huge wardrobe to look good this fall. Get one or two Brooks Brothers oxford shirts that fit the way you live, add a merino sweater, and you're set for most of the season. Save cashmere and the American-Made oxford for the holiday sales.
Before you shop, bookmark our Brooks Brothers promo codes page. We keep it updated with the latest offers and will add the Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals as soon as they go live. Want more ideas? Read our guide to the best Brooks Brothers clothing essentials on sale.